Search and Filter

Navigating The Ethical And Societal Impacts Of Generative Ai In Higher Computing Education

Date

AI Overview

Why it matters

Higher computing education urgently needs ethical and societal perspectives as generative AI spreads rapidly. Existing research has focused heavily on technical capabilities and pedagogy, leaving critical ethical, societal, and policy implications largely underexplored.

Study at a glance
  • Question: How does generative AI ethically, socially, and institutionally impact higher computing education?
  • Setting and data: Global higher education, 293 reviewed research papers published since 2020 and 21 institutional generative AI university policies.
  • Method: Systematic literature review, criterion-based and qualitative policy analysis, and conceptual framework derivation with dilemma analysis.
  • AI tools: ChatGPT, OpenAI Codex, GitHub Copilot, GPT-4, GPT-3.5, DeepSeek
Key findings
  • Most literature on ethical impacts focused on academic integrity, cheating, and detection, while areas like sustainability, power dynamics, and property rights received far less attention.
  • University policies sit along a continuum ranging from virtue-focused intellectual principles to prescriptive compliance-focused rules emphasizing academic misconduct and legal liability.
  • The authors developed the Ethical and Societal Impacts Framework to address persistent tensions across individual, institutional, and societal levels, such as cognitive offloading versus critical partnership.

Summary drafted with AI from the full paper and may contain errors. See the full paper for details.

Generative AI (GenAI) presents societal and ethical challenges related to equity, academic integrity, bias, and data provenance. In this paper, we outline the goals, methodology and deliverables of their collaborative research, considering the ethical and societal impacts of GenAI in higher computing education. A systematic literature review that addresses a wide set of issues and topics covering the rapidly emerging technology of GenAI from the perspective of its ethical and societal impacts is presented. This paper then presents an evaluation of a broad international review of a set of university adoption, guidelines, and policies related to the use of GenAI and the implications for computing education. The Ethical and Societal Impacts-Framework (ESI-Framework), derived from the literature and policy review and evaluation, outlines the ethical and societal impacts of GenAI in computing education. This work synthesizes existing research and considers the implications for computing higher education. Educators, computing professionals and policy makers facing dilemmas related to the integration of GenAI in their respective contexts may use this framework to guide decision-making in the age of GenAI.