Search and Filter

An Emancipatory Vision For Designing (Generative) AI For Learner Flourishing

Date

AI Overview

Why it matters

Generative AI risks pushing learners toward over-reliance, metacognitive laziness, and social isolation. Existing human-centered design methods remain insufficient to guide educational technology toward learner agency and flourishing within complex educational systems.

Study at a glance
  • Question: How should educational generative AI be designed to foster learner agency and flourishing instead of dependency?
  • Setting and data: Not stated in the paper
  • Method: Conceptual analysis and design framework proposal (position paper)
Key findings
  • Current AI in education often relies on problematic assumptions, including treating agency as a zero-sum game, overestimating predictability in complex systems, and presuming infinite resources for permanent scaffolding.
  • Ten design principles should guide educational AI, emphasizing living-creature agency, user appropriation, fading scaffolding, screen exiting, emotional detachment, value syncretism, uncertainty, learner resourcefulness, metacognition, and socio-technical interoperability.
  • A multi-stage methodology is proposed to elicit multi-level stakeholder values, deploy minimal viable interventions, evaluate multi-level outcomes across timeframes, and iteratively adapt designs.

Summary drafted with AI from the full paper and may contain errors. See the full paper for details.

The hype around generative AI seems to promise unprecedented productivity (and learning) gains. However, these technologies' increasing agentic features seem to push learners towards individualism (or individual isolation), over-reliance, and dependence on them. Human-centered design approaches (e.g., value-sensitive design) assume that, by unearthing human needs, preferences, and values, technology researchers/designers may avoid such dangers, which are driven by wider systemic factors like economic incentives or inherent human limitations (e.g., our tendency to seek, in the moment, the easiest path of action). Yet, so far these efforts seem insufficient to guide our design of educational technology that avoids the aforementioned dependency and isolation dangers, while finding widespread adoption. This paper presents an alternative, more emancipatory vision for future educational AI technology, oriented towards learner flourishing while considering the wider complex systems they inhabit, including tentative design principles and an overall design methodology. Yet, many open questions remain before this vision can be realized.