Search and Filter

A Survey On Feedback Types In Automated Programming Assessment Systems

Date

AI Overview

Why it matters

Automated programming assessment systems frequently rely on basic compiler or unit test feedback, while comparisons with newer large language model feedback remain largely unexplored regarding their quality and effects on student performance.

Study at a glance
  • Question: How do compiler, unit test, and AI-generated feedback affect students' perceptions, problem-solving, and task performance?
  • Setting and data: Two Austrian universities, Autumn 2023 to Spring 2024, 212 first-year undergraduate students in introductory programming courses.
  • Method: Mixed methods experiment and surveys across three programming exercises, analyzing submission logs and Technology Acceptance Model responses.
  • AI tools: GPT-3.5-Turbo
Key findings
  • Students receiving AI feedback achieved the highest average correctness score of 65.44, significantly outperforming unit test feedback (57.52) and compiler feedback (41.41).
  • Students rated unit test feedback highest for quality and usefulness, with 56% preferring it over AI feedback (26%) and compiler feedback (18%).
  • AI feedback led students to submit significantly more attempts (average 8.95) and take longer intervals between submissions (average 113.13 seconds) than other feedback types.

Summary drafted with AI from the full paper and may contain errors. See the full paper for details.

With the recent rapid increase in digitization across all major industries, acquiring programming skills has increased the demand for introductory programming courses. This has further resulted in universities integrating programming courses into a wide range of curricula, including not only technical studies but also business and management fields of study. Consequently, additional resources are needed for teaching, grading, and tutoring students with diverse educational backgrounds and skills. As part of this, Automated Programming Assessment Systems (APASs) have emerged, providing scalable and high-quality assessment systems with efficient evaluation and instant feedback. Commonly, APASs heavily rely on predefined unit tests for generating feedback, often limiting the scope and level of detail of feedback that can be provided to students. With the rise of Large Language Models (LLMs) in recent years, new opportunities have emerged as these technologies can enhance feedback quality and personalization. To investigate how different feedback mechanisms in APASs are perceived by students, and how effective they are in supporting problem-solving, we have conducted a large-scale study with over 200 students from two different universities. Specifically, we compare baseline Compiler Feedback, standard Unit Test Feedback, and advanced LLM-based Feedback regarding perceived quality and impact on student performance. Results indicate that while students rate unit test feedback as the most helpful, AI-generated feedback leads to significantly better performances. These findings suggest combining unit tests and AI-driven guidance to optimize automated feedback mechanisms and improve learning outcomes in programming education.