Search and Filter

Are They Just Delegating? Cross-Sample Predictions On University Students' & Teachers' Use Of AI

Date

AI Overview

Why it matters

Accurate mutual predictions of AI use are fundamental for teacher-student trust in higher education. However, empirical evidence comparing their actual AI adoption and assessing how accurately each group predicts the other's use is lacking.

Study at a glance
  • Question: How often do university instructors and students use AI, and how accurately do they predict each other's use?
  • Setting and data: German universities, 123 teachers and 113 students, surveyed starting May 2025.
  • Method: Online survey with incentivized cross-sample prediction tasks, analyzed using linear mixed-effects regression models.
Key findings
  • Students reported using AI more frequently and delegating tasks to AI to a greater extent than teachers across five of six academic tasks, with translation being the only exception.
  • Both teachers and students substantially overestimated the other group's AI use frequency (by 1.02 points on a 5-point scale) and delegation (by 25.89 points on a 100-point scale).
  • Teachers were no more accurate than students in predicting the other group's frequency of AI use or degree of AI delegation.

Summary drafted with AI from the full paper and may contain errors. See the full paper for details.

Mutual trust between teachers and students is a prerequisite for effective teaching, learning, and assessment in higher education. Accurate predictions about the other group's use of generative artificial intelligence (AI) are fundamental for such trust. However, the disruptive rise of AI has transformed academic work practices, raising important questions about how teachers and students use these tools and how well they can estimate each other's usage. While the frequency of use is well studied, little is known about how AI is used, and comparisons with similar practices are rare. This study surveyed German university teachers (N = 113) and students (N = 123) on the frequency of AI use and the degree of delegation across six identical academic tasks. Participants also provided incentivized cross-sample predictions of the other group's AI use to assess the accuracy of their predictions. We find that students reported higher use of AI and greater delegation than teachers. Both groups significantly overestimated the other group's use, with teachers predicting very frequent use and high delegation by students, and students assuming teachers use AI similarly to themselves. These findings reveal a perception gap between teachers' and students' expectations and actual AI use. Such gaps may hinder trust and effective collaboration, underscoring the need for open dialogue about AI practices in academia and for policies that support the equitable and transparent integration of AI tools in higher education.