Repository Feedback

Your feedback helps us improve the repository's content relevance and usability. Please share your thoughts to help us better serve researchers and practitioners.

Submit feedback

Submit a research study

Contribute to the repository:

Add a paper

Text Production and Comprehension by Human and Artificial Intelligence: Interdisciplinary Workshop Report

Authors
Patrick Bolger,
Morten H. Christiansen,
Bill Cope,
Pablo Contreras Kallens,
Mary Kalantzis,
Kyle Mahowald,
Martin Pickering,
Michael Ramscar,
Alina Reznitskaya,
Leila Wehbe,
Wei Xu,
Evgeny Chukharev,
Emily Dux Speltz,
Mark Torrance,
Kimberly Becker,
Phuong Nguyen,
Dan Song
Date
Publisher
arXiv
This report synthesizes the outcomes of a recent interdisciplinary workshop that brought together leading experts in cognitive psychology, language learning, and artificial intelligence (AI)-based natural language processing (NLP). The workshop, funded by the National Science Foundation, aimed to address a critical knowledge gap in our understanding of the relationship between AI language models and human cognitive processes in text comprehension and composition. Through collaborative dialogue across cognitive, linguistic, and technological perspectives, workshop participants examined the underlying processes involved when humans produce and comprehend text, and how AI can both inform our understanding of these processes and augment human capabilities. The workshop revealed emerging patterns in the relationship between large language models (LLMs) and human cognition, with highlights on both the capabilities of LLMs and their limitations in fully replicating human-like language understanding and generation. Key findings include the potential of LLMs to offer insights into human language processing, the increasing alignment between LLM behavior and human language processing when models are fine-tuned with human feedback, and the opportunities and challenges presented by human-AI collaboration in language tasks. By synthesizing these findings, this report aims to guide future research, development, and implementation of LLMs in cognitive psychology, linguistics, and education. It emphasizes the importance of ethical considerations and responsible use of AI technologies while striving to enhance human capabilities in text comprehension and production through effective human-AI collaboration.
Study at a glance
  • Question: How do AI language models compare to human reading and writing, and how can they support human abilities?
  • Setting and data: Recent workshop with experts in cognitive psychology, language learning, and artificial intelligence
  • Method: Synthesis of collaborative discussions from an interdisciplinary expert workshop
Why it matters

There is a critical knowledge gap in understanding the relationship between AI language models and human cognitive processes in text comprehension and composition.

Key findings
  • In an interdisciplinary expert workshop, large language models showed strong capabilities but could not fully replicate human-like language understanding and text generation.
  • AI models align more closely with human language processing when they are trained using human feedback.
  • AI models show potential to illuminate human language processes while presenting both opportunities and challenges for human-AI collaboration on language tasks.

Summary drafted with AI from the paper’s abstract and may contain errors. See the full paper for details.

Who is the user?