Date
AI Overview
Why it matters
Understanding AI's impact requires examining it as infrastructure rather than a neutral tool, showing how it restructures teacher expertise and epistemic agency rather than focusing solely on output accuracy, bias, or efficiency.
Study at a glance
- Question: How do generative AI tools reshape teachers' epistemic agency and professional knowledge practices?
- Setting and data: Promotional materials, documentation, interfaces, and demonstration videos of two educational AI platforms (MagicSchool AI and Brisk).
- Method: Technical investigation analyzing system interfaces, defaults, affordances, and workflows.
- AI tools: MagicSchool AI, Brisk
Key findings
- AI lesson planning and feedback systems exhibit epistemic substitution by performing core cognitive operations that are essential for developing professional teaching expertise.
- The platforms prioritize efficiency and present opaque, decontextualized outputs, which structurally rewards quick acceptance over critical scrutiny and pedagogical refinement.
- Sustained reliance on these efficiency-optimized systems risks cultivating habits of deference to AI, potentially deskilling educators and eroding independent professional judgment over time.
Summary drafted with AI from the full paper and may contain errors. See the full paper for details.
AI systems are increasingly embedded in practices where humans have traditionally exercised epistemic agency, the capacity to actively engage in knowledge formation and validation. This paper argues that understanding AI's impact on epistemic agency requires analyzing these systems as epistemic infrastructures rather than as neutral tools. Drawing on theories of technological mediation and distributed cognition, I advance a framework that foregrounds how AI systems reconfigure the conditions under which epistemic agency can be exercised. The framework specifies three analytical conditions: affordances for skilled epistemic actions, support for epistemic sensitivity, and implications for habit formation. I apply this framework to AI systems deployed in education, a domain where epistemic agency is both professionally essential and ethically significant. Analysis of AI lesson planning and feedback tools reveals patterns of epistemic substitution: while useful for efficiently handling teaching tasks, these systems perform cognitive operations without sustaining skilled epistemic actions, epistemic sensitivity, or virtuous habit formation, potentially preventing the cultivation of professional judgment that relies on these practices. The findings contribute to philosophical debates about AI and human agency by specifying mechanisms through which infrastructural embedding shapes epistemic possibilities, and offer design principles for AI systems that sustain rather than supplant human epistemic agency.
Research Categories
What is the application?
Who is the user?
Who age?
Why use AI?
Study design
Methods
AI tools
Publication Source
Publisher
arXiv
