Search and Filter

How Physics Professors Use And Frame Generative Ai Tools

Date

AI Overview

Why it matters

Generative AI is rapidly reshaping physics teaching and research, yet little is known about how physics faculty use, perceive, and respond to these tools.

Study at a glance
  • Question: How do physics professors use and frame generative AI tools in their teaching and research?
  • Setting and data: 12 physics professors at a major Scandinavian research university, interviewed in late spring and early fall 2024.
  • Method: Interviews analyzed using thematic analysis and epistemic framing
  • AI tools: ChatGPT, Gemini, Co-Pilot, Claude
Key findings
  • Professors framed generative AI through six overlapping epistemic frames, identifying it as a threat, a source of knowledge, a discussion partner, a text-processing tool, a coding tool, and a labor-saving device.
  • Concerns about generative AI threatening genuine learning and assessment permeated discussions, with warrants for this threat frame appearing roughly twice as often as any other frame.
  • Eight professors had modified course assessment formats or reaffirmed closed-form testing, while others addressed integrity through declarations, dialogue, and reflective tasks.

Summary drafted with AI from the full paper and may contain errors. See the full paper for details.

Generative AI is rapidly reshaping how physicists teach, learn, and conduct research, yet little is known about how physics faculty are responding to these changes. We interviewed 12 physics professors at a major Scandinavian research university to explore their uses and perceptions of Generative AI (GenAI) in both teaching and research. Using the theoretical framework of epistemic framing, we conducted a thematic analysis that identified 19 overlapping practices, ranging from coding and literature review to assessment and feedback. From these practices, we derived six overlapping epistemic frames through which professors make sense of GenAI: as a threat to genuine learning and assessment, a source of knowledge, a discussion partner, a text-processing tool, a coding tool, and a labor-saving device. While the latter five position GenAI as a useful tool in the physicists' toolbox, the threat frame represented an overarching concern that colored all other frames. These findings reveal how GenAI is beginning to transform what it means to be a physicist, highlighting both opportunities for innovation and challenges for academic integrity and learning.