Date
AI Overview
Why it matters
Higher education AI discussions often focus narrowly on compliance and containment. Moving beyond whether students should use generative AI, educators must explore how students position AI in their practice and learn when to refuse it.
Study at a glance
- Question: How do students use, position, and deliberately refuse generative AI across an engineering design course?
- Setting and data: A 13-week design course with approximately 500 first-year engineering and architecture students at Singapore University of Technology and Design; 13 reflection logs and 8 award briefs.
- Method: Design-based research using open and axial qualitative coding of student reflection logs, illustrated briefs, and instructor observations.
- AI tools: ChatGPT, ChatGPT Plus, GPT-4, GPT-4o, Whisper-1, Midjourney
Key findings
- Students used generative AI as a tool for bounded delegation like rapid sketch rendering and debugging, re-investing saved time into prototype iterations and deeper design work.
- Treated as a teammate, students used AI for co-design and critique, running identical prompts across multiple models to spot blind spots and cross-validate hallucinations.
- Students intentionally refused AI during empathetic user research and hands-on making, or chose non-use after discovering misleading hardware recommendations.
Summary drafted with AI from the full paper and may contain errors. See the full paper for details.
This pilot study traces students' reflections on the use of AI in a 13-week
foundational design course enrolling over 500 first-year engineering and
architecture students at the Singapore University of Technology and Design. The
course was an AI-enhanced design course, with several interventions to equip
students with AI based design skills. Students were required to reflect on
whether the technology was used as a tool (instrumental assistant), a teammate
(collaborative partner), or neither (deliberate non-use). By foregrounding this
three-way lens, students learned to use AI for innovation rather than just
automation and to reflect on agency, ethics, and context rather than on prompt
crafting alone. Evidence stems from coursework artefacts: thirteen structured
reflection spreadsheets and eight illustrated briefs submitted, combined with
notes of teachers and researchers. Qualitative coding of these materials
reveals shared practices brought about through the inclusion of Gen-AI,
including accelerated prototyping, rapid skill acquisition, iterative prompt
refinement, purposeful "switch-offs" during user research, and emergent
routines for recognizing hallucinations. Unexpectedly, students not only
harnessed Gen-AI for speed but (enabled by the tool-teammate-neither triage)
also learned to reject its outputs, invent their own hallucination fire-drills,
and divert the reclaimed hours into deeper user research, thereby transforming
efficiency into innovation. The implications of the approach we explore shows
that: we can transform AI uptake into an assessable design habit; that
rewarding selective non-use cultivates hallucination-aware workflows; and,
practically, that a coordinated bundle of tool access, reflection, role
tagging, and public recognition through competition awards allows AI based
innovation in education to scale without compromising accountability.
Research Categories
What is the application?
Who is the user?
Who age?
Study design
Methods
AI tools
Publication Source
Publisher
arXiv
