Date
AI Overview
Why it matters
Generative AI could spread benefits unevenly across society through digital divides. Understanding how individuals learn about and benefit from these tools in everyday settings is crucial for broader societal advancement.
Study at a glance
- Question: How do different demographic groups learn about and benefit from generative AI compared to traditional search engines?
- Setting and data: United States; online clickstream panel of 1,344 repeat ChatGPT users and 11,752 total verified users, November 2022 to May 2023.
- Method: Structural Bayesian learning model with latent classes and counterfactual policy simulations.
- AI tools: ChatGPT, GPT-3, GPT-4, OpenAI API
Key findings
- Users without college education, non-white individuals, and those with lower English literacy gain higher relative utility from ChatGPT, yet update their beliefs about its utility more slowly.
- Males, younger users, and workers with higher occupational exposure to AI gain greater utility per use and learn about ChatGPT's utility more rapidly.
- Users who initially form low perceptions of ChatGPT can fall into a persistent belief trap, though simulated early training of 200 to 400 uses substantially reduces this risk.
Summary drafted with AI from the full paper and may contain errors. See the full paper for details.
Recent advancements in generative AI, such as ChatGPT, have dramatically transformed how people access information. Despite its powerful capabilities, the benefits it provides may not be equally distributed among individuals, a phenomenon referred to as the digital divide. Building upon prior literature, we propose two forms of digital divide in the generative AI adoption process: (i) the learning divide, capturing individuals' heterogeneous abilities to update their perceived utility of ChatGPT; and (ii) the utility divide, representing differences in individuals' actual utility derived from per use of ChatGPT. To evaluate these two divides, we develop a Bayesian learning model that incorporates heterogeneities in both the utility and signal functions. Leveraging a large-scale clickstream dataset, we estimate the model and find significant learning and utility divides across various social characteristics. Interestingly, individuals without any college education, non-white individuals, and those with lower English literacy derive larger utility gains from ChatGPT, yet update their beliefs about its utility at a slower rate. Furthermore, males, younger individuals, and those in occupations with greater exposure to generative AI not only obtain higher utility per use from ChatGPT but also learn about its utility more rapidly. Besides, we document a phenomenon termed the belief trap, wherein users underestimate ChatGPT's utility, opt not to use the tool, and thereby lack new experiences to update their perceptions, leading to continued underutilization. Our simulation further demonstrates that the learning divide can significantly affect the probability of falling into the belief trap, another form of the digital divide in adoption outcomes (i.e., outcome divide); however, offering training programs can alleviate the belief trap and mitigate the divide.
Research Categories
Who is the user?
Who age?
Why use AI?
Study design
AI tools
Datasets
Publication Source
Publisher
arXiv
