Search and Filter

Complex Networks Map Test Anxiety And Wellbeing Levels In Students And Chatgpt

Date

AI Overview

Why it matters

Routine grading rarely measures students' test anxiety or emotional wellbeing. When academic stress remains unnoticed, it can reinforce avoidance behaviors and harm performance.

Study at a glance
  • Question: How do students, experts, and AI models semantically frame exams, grades, anxiety, and wellbeing?
  • Setting and data: Italy; 497 human participants (experts, high schoolers, undergraduates) and 497 simulated AI personas; collected between 2023 and 2025 alongside prior datasets.
  • Method: Network analysis of word associations and valence ratings (behavioral forma mentis networks).
  • AI tools: GPT-OSS 20B, ChatGPT, GPT-4
Key findings
  • Across all human student groups, exams and grades were framed negatively, clustering around ideas of failure, pressure, and negative emotions such as fear.
  • Human students' mental networks linked anxiety and exams three to four times more closely than simulated AI models, which kept them largely segregated.
  • Human students grounded anxiety and wellbeing in concrete daily experiences, whereas AI models associated them with abstract, diagnostic, and clinical concepts.

Summary drafted with AI from the full paper and may contain errors. See the full paper for details.

Academic STEM evaluation can elicit anxiety, yet routine grading rarely captures how students semantically frame exams and wellbeing. We reconstruct these framings using behavioural forma mentis networks (BFMNs), that is, feature-rich networks of concepts linked by memory recalls and enriched with affective ratings and concreteness norms. We build BFMNs from 994 participants spanning STEM experts (N1 = 59), Italian high-schoolers (N2 = 206), physics undergraduates (N3 = 10), psychology undergraduates with math-anxiety levels (N4 = 301), and simulated students (N5 = 497) personified by a large language model (GPT-OSS 20B). Across all human groups, the concepts "exam" and "grade" were (i) perceived negatively, (ii) connected primarily to negatively valenced memory recalls, indicating a clustering of negative emotions around assessment, and (iii) framed through concepts eliciting fear and anticipation in most groups, including physics undergraduates (z-scores in the range [2.04, 2.53]). The semantic neighbourhoods of "anxiety" and "exam" overlapped three times more in human students than in GPT-based simulations, providing structural evidence of test anxiety in student populations. By contrast, experts displayed a neutral and more concrete network neighbourhood for "exam" (z = 1.87), with no clear trace of test anxiety. These negative assessment framings coexisted with positive representations of "wellbeing", which were rich in concrete associations in humans but linked to more abstract concepts in GPT digital twins. Overall, our results show that BFMNs offer a quantitative and interpretable framework to study academic anxiety and to distinguish human affective framing from current AI-based simulations

Research Categories

What is the application?
Who is the user?
Why use AI?

Publication Source

Publisher
arXiv