Search and Filter

Research Evidence for Educators

What happens when teachers use AI? This page brings together the strongest studies so far, grouped by what they found. Each study card shows what was tested, who took part and the result, with a link to the full paper in the Repository.

The findings and study summaries on this page come from The Evidence Base on AI in K–12: A November 2026 Review, SCALE's synthesis of randomized controlled trials and quasi-experimental studies in the Research Repository.

Walker, S., Fesler, L., Martinez Claeys, JP., Agnew, C., & Loeb, S. (2026). https://doi.org/10.26300/80wn-ca81

Key finding

AI and Feedback

AI can increase the quantity and quality of feedback educators give to students, help teachers encourage student assignment completion, and give real-time instructional suggestions that improve educator practice.

AI to support educator feedback to students

AI may enable educators to provide more high-quality feedback.

AI-generated drafts increased the likelihood that teaching assistants at a U.S. university provided feedback to students and led to longer comments (Mahinpei et al., 2026). Students rated this feedback as similarly useful to feedback written without AI assistance. Another study at a university in the U.S. found that teaching assistants who received AI suggestions gave nearly twice as much feedback, with higher-quality feedback and broader coverage of rubric criteria, without increasing the time spent grading submissions and providing feedback (Lu et al., 2026). Students receiving this AI-assisted feedback produced higher-scoring revisions, but did not perform significantly better on a subsequent post-test.

The 2 studies

Randomized controlled trialAI used by educators

AI Assistance For Discretionary Work: Increasing Feedback Provision In Higher Education

Mahinpei et al. (2026)

What was tested
After grading submissions, TAs received optional AI-drafted feedback comments they could use, edit, or ignore, compared with no draft.
Who took part
11 TAs and 88 U.S. undergraduates in an ML course
What they found
AI drafts increased the likelihood of providing feedback by about 11 percentage points and increased comment length. Time per character and rated usefulness were similar.
Randomized controlled trialAI used by educators

AI-Mediated Feedback Improves Student Revisions: A Randomized Trial with FeedbackWriter in a Large Undergraduate Course

Lu et al. (2026)

What was tested
Teaching assistants (TAs) graded essays with or without AI-suggested rubric comments they could adopt, edit, or discard.
Who took part
11 TAs and 354 U.S. undergraduates in an economics course
What they found
AI-assisted TAs provided more and better-rated feedback without taking longer. Students receiving AI-assisted feedback produced stronger revisions but did not score significantly higher on a later post-test.

AI for direct student feedback

AI may support educators by generating student-facing feedback that produces outcomes similar to educator feedback. More personalized AI support may also modestly improve academic outcomes.

Real-time multimodal AI feedback produced learning gains similar to prewritten educator comments and was rated clearer, more specific, and more motivating by college learners in the U.S. (Zhao et al., 2026). Results were similar in German secondary schools, where AI-generated and teacher-provided writing feedback produced no statistically significant differences in revisions or subsequent writing performance (Meyer et al., 2026). Beyond feedback alone, individualized AI messages combining performance feedback, motivational prompts, and study guidance modestly improved midterm performance and final-exam participation in a large online course in Türkiye, but did not significantly improve final exam scores (Ozturk et al., 2026).

The 3 studies

Randomized controlled trialAI used by students

Llm-Based Multimodal Feedback Produces Equivalent Learning And Better Student Perceptions Than Educator Feedback

Zhao et al. (2026)

What was tested
Students received GPT-5-generated multimedia feedback, including personalized text, slides, and optional audio, or feedback written by a human educator.
Who took part
197 U.S. college students recruited through Prolific
What they found
AI and educator feedback produced statistically equivalent learning gains. Students rated AI feedback clearer, more specific, more motivating, and less cognitively demanding, with similar trust and perceived correctness.
Randomized controlled trialAI used by students

Comparing Teacher And AI-Generated Feedback In The Writing Classroom: Experimental Results From Secondary School Classrooms

Meyer et al. (2026)

What was tested
Students received feedback on English essay drafts from teachers or GPT-4, with AI feedback delivered immediately or after the same delay as teacher feedback.
Who took part
391 German students in grades 10 and 11
What they found
Revision quality and subsequent writing performance did not significantly differ. Immediate AI feedback was perceived as more useful and motivating but did not increase revision time or editing extent.
Randomized controlled trialAI used by students

Who Benefits from LLM-Generated Learning Support Messages? Causal Evidence on Treatment Effect Heterogeneity

Ozturk et al. (2026)

What was tested
Online economics students received personalized GPT-4o learning-support messages throughout the semester, including feedback, motivation, study advice, and assessments, versus standard course materials.
Who took part
28,833 undergraduates in an online economics course in Türkiye
What they found
AI-generated messages modestly increased midterm scores and final-exam participation but did not significantly affect final-exam scores or midterm participation.

AI for progress monitoring

AI-generated summaries of student progress for teachers can increase assignment completion, even if they do not improve academic performance.

In one study, K–12 students in the U.S. were more likely to start and complete assignments if their teachers received AI summaries of assignment reports (Lim et al., 2026). The AI summaries included an overview of the assignment score and completion rate, common learning gaps, students who could use additional support, and instructional recommendations (such as concepts to review). However, class-level assignment scores did not improve, even though more students started and completed the assignments.

The study

Randomized controlled trialAI used by educators

LLM-Generated Summaries For Teachers: A Randomized Field Experiment In A Digital Learning Platform

Lim et al. (2026)

What was tested
Teachers received standard ASSISTments reports or reports with on-demand AI summaries identifying learning patterns, struggling students, and instructional suggestions over eight weeks.
Who took part
874 U.S. teachers
What they found
Despite no significant effect of AI summaries on teachers’ logged behavior, their students started and completed more assignments, though the value-added measure did not significantly improve.

Earlier evidence

Previous finding (March 2026 review): AI can deliver automated feedback on teaching and student progress, improving instructional quality and student outcomes. AI can offer real-time instructional suggestions that improve educator practice and student outcomes, particularly in messaging-based settings.

Studies from the March 2026 review

Randomized controlled trialAI used by educators

Tutor CoPilot: A Human-AI Approach for Scaling Real-Time Expertise

Wang et al. (2025)

What was tested
Tutor CoPilot gave real-time, expert-like AI suggestions to human tutors during math sessions vs. no suggestions. Students received tutoring over the course of two months.
Who took part
900 tutors and 1,800 K–12 students from Title I schools in the U.S.
What they found
Access to Tutor CoPilot significantly improved student mastery of lesson topics (4–14 percentage points), and the benefits were largest for students of lower-rated and less-experienced tutors.
Randomized controlled trialAI used by educators

M-Powering Teachers: Natural Language Processing Powered Feedback Improves 1:1 Instruction and Student Outcomes

Demszky et al. (2023)

What was tested
M-Powering Teachers (automated NLP-based feedback to teachers on their "uptake" of student ideas) vs. no feedback. Access to the automated feedback was provided over 10 sessions.
Who took part
414 instructors from a U.S.-based online platform for high school students
What they found
Automated feedback improved instructors’ uptake of student ideas by 10%, reduced instructor’s talk time by 5% and improved students’ experience with the program.
Randomized controlled trialAI used by educators

Home-Tutoring Services Assisted with Technology: Investigating the Role of Artificial Intelligence Using a Randomized Field Experiment

Kim et al. (2021)

What was tested
Providing AI-generated weekly student progress/achievement reports to home tutors vs. no reports. Tutors in the treatment group received AI-generated reports for 12 weeks.
Who took part
234 tutors and 2,220 students in South Korea.
What they found
AI reports significantly improved student academic performance, though "technology overload" hindered the benefit for certain tutors.
Randomized controlled trialAI used by educators

Student Learning Benefits Of A Mixed-Reality Teacher Awareness Tool In AI-Enhanced Classrooms

Holstein et al. (2018)

What was tested
Access to mixed-reality smart glasses providing real-time AI-generated student analytics to teachers vs. no access to analytics. Students worked with a tutor for a total of 60 minutes, spread across two classes over one week.
Who took part
286 middle school students and 8 teachers in the U.S.
What they found
Smart glasses allowed teachers to redirect attention to struggling students, narrowing the learning gap across prior performance levels.

Also in the March review: Demszky et al. (2025), automated feedback to teachers through TeachFX (not yet in the Repository).

Latest papers

The newest of 790 papers in the Repository where educators use AI.