Search and Filter

Questioning the Scope of AI Standardization in Learning, Education, and Training

Date

AI Overview

Why it matters

Clear terminology and well-defined scope are essential for formal standards, especially as rapidly evolving artificial intelligence reshapes learning technology and adopts terms with different meanings across fields.

Study at a glance
  • Question: How should standards bodies define the scope of artificial intelligence in learning, education, and training?
  • Setting and data: Not stated in the abstract
  • Method: Conceptual analysis
Key findings
  • Prior standards in learning technology focused on human teachers and learners, but emerging artificial intelligence tools require rethinking whether these roles are necessarily human.
  • Common educational terms like blended learning must expand beyond online and offline mixes to encompass mixed reality and human-AI symbiosis within Adaptive Instructional Systems.
  • Although learning and artificial intelligence share terminology, words mean different things across fields, requiring ethics and values to apply directly to AI within educational contexts.

Summary drafted with AI from the paper’s abstract and may contain errors. See the full paper for details.

Well-defined terminology and scope are essential in formal standardization work. In the broad domain of Information and Communications Technology (ICT) the necessity is even more so due to proliferation and appropriation of terms from other fields and public discourse - the term deep learning. In reviewing the emerging impact of Artificial Intelligence (AI) on the field of Information Technology for Learning, Education, and Training (ITLET), this paper highlights several questions that might assist in developing scope statements of new work items. While learners and teachers are very much foregrounded in past and present standardization efforts in ITLET, little attention has been placed until recently on whether these learners and teachers are necessarily human. Now that AI is a hot spot of innovation it is receiving considerable attention from standardization bodies such as ISO/IEC, IEEE and pan-European initiatives such as the Next Generation Internet. Thus, terminology such as blended learning necessarily now spans not just humans in a mix of online and offline learning, but also mixed reality and AI paradigms, developed to assist human learners in environments such as Adaptive Instructional Systems (AIS) that extend the scope and design of a learning experience where a symbiosis is formed between humans and AI. Although the fields of LET and AI may utilize similar terms, the language of AI is mathematics and terms can mean different things in each field. Nonetheless, in symbiotic learningcontexts where an AIS at times replaces a human teacher, a symbiosis between the human learner and the AIS occurs in such a way where both can exist as teacher and learner. While human ethics and values are preeminent in this new symbiosis, a shift towards a new intelligence nexus is signalled where ethics and values can also apply to AI in learning, education, and training (LET) contexts. In making sense of the scope of standardizati...

Research Categories

Who age?
Why use AI?

Publication Source

Publisher
IEEE